XRF of the WIF, hematite obtained from WIF and ore

Table 1 shows the elemental composition of the WIF and α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) obtained in this study and α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) reported by Abraham Muwanguzi et al.33. The composition of the WIF shows that the ({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) (68.6) has the highest concentration, follow by ({text{Al}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) (14.21). This result reveals that the WIF contains in high concentration, two amphoteric oxides suitable as a catalyst for biodiesel production. The processed WIF reveals the presence of α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) (74.43%), ({text{Al}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) (12%), ({text{MgO}}) (7.02) and ({text{CaO}}) (4.10) as the major elements, while other associated elements which include ({text{CuO }}) (0.36%), ({text{MnO}}) (0.39%), ({text{Cr}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) (0.30%), ({text{TiO}}_{2}) (0.01), ({text{ZnO}}) (0.63%), ({text{SiO}}_{2}) (0.87), ({text{Rb}}_{2} {text{O}}) (0.02) and ({text{Eu}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) (0.68) exist as traces in < 0.1%. This results revealed that the product of the WIF essentially contains α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) and ({text{Al}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) with fewer impurities which is similar to the results obtained from the hematite ore (α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) (92.6%), and ({text{Al}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) (1.35%) reported by Abraham Muwanguzi et al.33. Therefore, hematite synthesized from WIF by co-precipitation is an alternative to commercial ({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}).

Table 1 XRF analysis of the WIF and hematite (alpha { – }left( {{text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3} } right)).

TG–DTA of the hematite

Thermal stability of the α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) by the TG–DTA analyses are shown in Fig. 4. The thermograph shows three main regions of decomposition. At a lower temperature of about 300 °C, weight loss of 10 wt% was observed which was due to the breaking of weakly bonded water molecules by physio-sorption6. At an elevated temperature of between 300 and 500 °C, weight loss of 55 wt% and 25 wt% from 320 to 370 °C and 370 to 420 °C occurred respectively. These might be due to the condensation of sinol group (Si–O) compound present in the hematite. Although 10 wt% weight loss was recorded between 420 and 600 °C due to the decomposition of chemical components thus showing crystalline phase transformation1. The stability of the weight was experienced at a temperature above 500 °C which indicates that the α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) synthesized remains stable at that temperature and corroborates with the purity nature of the sample. Hence, the three main regions observed are physically adsorbed water, removal of chemically adsorbed water, and decomposition of chemical components, which corroborate the findings of Esmaeel Darezereshki34. The DTA shows an endothermic peak at 150 °C with a low weight loss of 0.5 wt% while the second step corresponds to a more significant weight loss of 18 wt% occurring at 300–370 °C, which is due to the combustible organic products present in the prepared sample. The third step revealed another significant weight loss of 5 wt% between the range of 370–440 °C, which is due to the transition phase of synthesized compounds. Finally, DTA shows an endothermic peak at 680 °C, thereafter, the curve becomes parallel to the temperature axis, which emphasizes the high stability of the α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}). It is worthy to note that no associated signal was noticed in the TGA curve when compared with the DTA curve. These confirm the crystallization and phase transition of the α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) according to Abdelmajid Lassoued et al.35. The TG–DTA curves obtained in this study is similar to the pattern shown by Muhammad Waseem et al.36.

Figure 4

TGA/DTA curves of the hematite.

Characterizations of the hematite and RBCs


Figure 5 shows the FTIR spectra of the α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) and RBCs within the range of 4,000–400 cm−1. The presence of water (OH) stretch was observed at 3,780–2,910 cm−1 region in all the samples. Also, the presence of a peak at 2,950 cm−1 can be attributed to C–H stretch. The peak at range 1,200–1,020 cm−1 characterized the feature of α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) which corresponds to the vibration of crystalline Fe–O mode37. The S=O symmetric and asymmetric vibration were observed at a wavenumber of 1,100–1,000 cm−1 for calcined-sulfonated samples (RBC500, RBC700, and RBC900), which could be as a result of the sulfur anion (({text{SO}}_{4}^{2 – })) chelating with iron cation (left( {{text{Fe}}^{3 + } } right)) on the catalysts6. In contrast, α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) which is un-sulfonated, did not show any band in that regions, indicating the absence of sulfate group. The appearance of two prominent spectra of the four samples from the region of 840–420 cm−1 can be attributed to the Fe–O vibration in the rhombohedral lattice of hematite35 and the characteristic of the crystalline α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) compound38.

Figure 5

FTIR spectra of the hematite, RBC500, RBC700 and RBC900.


The XRD spectra of the α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) and RBCs are depicted in Fig. 6, in which they all exhibited rhombohedral structure similar to Sivakumar et al.39 spectra. The XRD patterns show the crystallinity nature of the compounds present in the samples with definite Bragg’s peak at specific 2θ angles. The peaks appearing at 2θ range of 24.15°, 33.17°, 35.70°, 40.83°, 49.45°, 54.06°, 57.55°, 62.48°, and 63.90° are indexed to hkl (0 1 2), (1 0 4), (1 1 0), (1 1 3), (0 2 4), (1 1 6), (0 1 8), (2 1 4), (3 0 0) respectively, on crystallographic plane of α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}). This is comparable with the findings of Abdelmajid Lassoued et al.35. These can be attributed to the crystalline structures corresponding to pure α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) nanoparticles. The appearance of the highest peak at 33.17° indicates the presence of α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) according to Muhammad Waseem et al.36. While the narrowness of the sharp peaks indicate high crystallinity and high purity of the hematite according to Abdulmajid Lassoued et al.35. The hematite obtained in this study, therefore, can be of quality to replace off-the-shelf hematite for applications, such as sensors, catalysts, data storage materials, fine ceramics, pigments, and photo-electrochemical cells14. Similar intense peaks were observed for the RBCs, which also justify the high crystallinity of the catalysts. The spectra show majorly, the presence of (1) Hematite—α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) (JCPDS: 033-0664), (2) Aluminium hydrogen sulfate hydrate—({text{AlH}}left( {{text{SO}}_{4} } right)_{2} cdot {text{H}}_{2} {text{O}}) (JCPDS: 027-1006), (3) Rhomboclase—(left( {{text{H}}_{5} {text{O}}_{2} } right){text{Fe}}left( {{text{SO}}_{4} } right)_{2} left( {{text{H}}_{2} {text{O}}} right)_{2}) (JCPDS: 070-1820), and (4) Coquimbite—({text{Fe}}_{1.68} {text{Al}}_{.32} left( {{text{SO}}_{4} } right)_{3} left( {{text{H}}_{2} {text{O}}} right)_{9}) (JCPDS: 074-2406). These show that the product at each phase consists of pure compounds. Further identification of compounds represented by the peaks was done using the JCPDS file number as indicated in the bracket. While the mean crystalline size of each of the products was calculated using the Debye–Scherrer’s equation. The results of the crystalline size as shown in Table 2 for α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}), RBC500, RBC700 and RBC900 are 16.43, 9.77, 10.25 and 14.13 nm respectively. Although, the previous report gave an average particle size of α-Fe2O3 in the range of 30–70 nm39. However, in this study, the average particle size of α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) has been calculated as 16.43 nm. The difference between these values might be due to the difference in the process conditions such as agitation speed and calcination temperature. For the RBCs, it can be observed that the mean crystallite size of RBC500 nanoparticles is the minimum size while that of RBC900 is the maximum size. This signifies that the crystalline size increases with increasing calcination temperature which is the same pattern reported by Gaber et al.40.

Figure 6

XRD patterns of (a) α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}), (b) RBC500, (c) RBC700, and (d) RBC900. Chemical compounds in the products: (1) Hematite—α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}). (2) Aluminum hydrogen sulfate hydrate—({text{AlH}}left( {{text{SO}}_{4} } right)_{2} cdot {text{H}}_{2} {text{O}}). (3) Rhomboclase—(left( {{text{H}}_{5} {text{O}}_{2} } right){text{Fe}}left( {{text{SO}}_{4} } right)_{2} left( {{text{H}}_{2} {text{O}}} right)_{2}). (4) Coquimbite—({text{Fe}}_{1.68} {text{Al}}_{.32} left( {{text{SO}}_{4} } right)_{3} left( {{text{H}}_{2} {text{O}}} right)_{9}).

Table 2 Crystalline size, average particle size, surface area, pore-volume and pore diameter of the products.

SEM/EDS and PSD analyses

The SEM/EDS analyses studied include morphology, elemental composition, and particle size distributions (PSD) as shown in Fig. 7a(i–iii)–d(i–iii). Figure 7a(i) revealed the results of the hematite (left( {alpha {text{-} text{ Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3} } right)) with the morphology showing clusters of rough surfaces laced with pores and irregular shapes. Figure 7a(ii) is the EDS of the hematite spectrum which shows that the particle consists of ({text{Fe}}/{text{Cl}}/{text{Al}}/{text{O}}) with evaluated molar ratio 3/1/0.5/2. The EDS elemental composition confirmed the formation of α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}), especially considering the presence of ({text{Fe}}^{3 + }) around the line energy of oxygen (0–2 keV). This is similar to the findings of Nagaraj Basavegowda et al.14, where hematite can be closely packed with oxygen lattice. The appearance of sharp peaks between the line energy of 6 and 8 keV in the EDS spectra confirmed the presence of elemental iron37. The traces of chlorine were present and may have been introduced possibly during the treatment with ({text{HCl}}) while the Al and C originated from the WIF as impurities. Figure 7a(iii) shows the particle size distribution (PSD) of the hematite. The PSD indicates the dominance of particle size range of 181–300 nm, which is in agreement with the SEM morphology as shown in Fig. 7a(i). This finding suggests that the α-Fe2O3 is a nanoparticle of sub-300 nm.

Figure 7

(a,b) (i) SEM, (ii) EDX and (iii) PSD of WIF to Synthesize (a) Fe2O3 (300 nm PS), and (b) RBC500 (200 nm PS). Figure 7 (c,d) (i) SEM, (ii) EDX and (iii) PSD of WIF to Synthesize (c) RBC700 (200 nm PS), and (d) RBC900 (200 nm PS).

After calcination at 500 °C and sulphonation by ({text{H}}_{2} {text{SO}}_{4}) of the initial α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) to obtain RBC500, the morphology reveals less agglomeration with improved smooth surface and pores as shown in Fig. 7b(i). The EDS result in Fig. 7b(ii) shows Fe/S/Al/O with molar ratio 7/1/0.3/5 showing α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) as a dominant compound with the presence of sulfur. This result revealed that the calcination process removed Cl and that the sulphonation process introduced sulfur compound into the new compound (RBC500). It could also be observed that the PSD was altered possibly due to calcination, and the RBC500 formed exhibited particle size ranges that are rather bi-modal as shown in Fig. 7b(iii). The PSD, however, is evenly distributed in the sub-200 nm which is lower than that of α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) (sub-300 nm). In addition, the SEM morphology of RBC500 (Fig. 7b(i)) is an indication that the new particle sizes were formed after calcination and sulphonation.

Figure 7c(i–iii) is the morphology, EDS and PSD of the RBC700 respectively. Figure 7c(i) shows that the particles are clustered together and have an ovoid shape with a crystalline surface of the porous structure. The EDS of RBC700 as shown in Fig. 7c(ii) reveals that the Fe/S/Al/O has a molar ratio of 1/1/0.28/4 which indicates that ({text{Fe}}^{3 + }) and ({text{SO}}_{4}^{2 – }) dominate the sample with traces of Al. The PSD also exhibited a bi-modal structure as shown in Fig. 7c(iii). The figure reveals that the particle sizes are in the sub-200 nm range and are evenly distributed to sub-20 nm in the ranges of 20–200 nm. Among the ranges, sub-20 nm has the highest particles of 125 and next is 61–80 nm with particle numbers of 98. This shows that most of the particles in the RBC700 are sub-100 nm, indicating a nano-catalyst.

Figure 7d(i) shows the morphology of the RBC900, which reveals a well-arranged, smooth, clean and clear crystalline particles. The particles are intercalated and well-aligned rhombohedral centred hexagonal-shaped nano-plates which is one of the characteristics of the hematite compound as reported by Basavegowda et al.14. The width of the plates is in microns and is sub-200 nm thick with a well-arranged regular porous structure. The particles are visible and seen as hexagonal crystals with the size varying from 500 nm to 1,000 nm. Figure 7d(ii) shows EDS of the RBC900 as Fe/S/Al/O with molar ratio 1/1/0.08/4 which indicates Al–({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3} /{text{SO}}_{4}) as the dominant compounds. Figure 7d(iii) reveals the PSD of RBC900, which shows the dominance of a particle size range of 41–60 nm. This result is in agreement with the SEM morphology as shown in Fig. 7d(i) and it suggests that the RBC900 is a nanoparticle of sub-100 nm. Generally, the particle size decreases as the calcination temperature increases. This is similar to the findings of Salam Al-jaberi et al.6 which confirms the significant effects of calcination temperature on the nano-synthesis of the catalysts.


The particle size distribution and average particle size of the α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) and RBCs were analyzed by the DLS and the results obtained are shown in Fig. 8 and Table 2. Figure 8a–d show the particle size distribution of the α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}), RBC500, RBC700 and RBC900 respectively, which follow similar patterns as the PSD. The average particle size of each of the samples as shown in the table are 304.4, 259.6, 169.5 and 95.62 nm for α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}), RBC500, RBC700 and RBC900 respectively. It can be seen from Fig. 8a that the particle size distribution for the α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) lies between 10 and 1,500 nm. Whereas, Fig. 8b–d shows that the particle size distribution for the RBCs lies between 10 and 400 nm. This suggests that the thermal treatment of the α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) further reduced the particle size distribution of the RBCs. The RBC900 has the smallest average particles size, followed by RBC700 and the highest is RBC500 as shown in the table. Thus, as the calcination temperature increased, the nanoparticle size decreases which confirms the results of the PSD. The results show that all the RBCs have an average particle size less than 300 nm and also reveals that there is a significant improvement to the particle size based on the calcination temperature between 500 and 900 °C. This shows that each of the RBCs has more loading sites for the transesterification process, as the smaller the average particle size of the solid catalyst, the larger the surface area, which makes more loading sites available for catalytic activity. The nanoparticle size is also directly proportional to the magnetophoretic forces (Fmag). Since the average particle size of the RBCs is between 90 and 260 nm, hence, the Fmag is sufficient to overcome both thermal randomization energy and viscous hindrances of the transesterification reaction41. The findings from the DLS corroborates the PSD of the SEM which confirms that the solid acid catalysts in this study are nanocatalysts in nature.

Figure 8

DLS of (a) α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) synthesized from WIF (b) RBC500 (c) RBC700 and (d) RBC900.


The catalytic activity of any solid catalyst has been reported to depend on its surface area, pore-volume, and pore diameter. Hence, the more the surface area (SA), pore volume (PV), and pore diameter (PD), the more the catalytic activity of the catalyst in the process42. In this study, the SA for α-Fe2O3, RBC500, RBC700 and RBC900 are 107.1, 434.9, 457.5 and 471.3 m2/g respectively, PV; 0.541, 0.144, 0.153 and 0.160 cc/g respectively and PD; 9.236, 5.740, 5.766 and 5.842 nm respectively as shown in Table 2. The parameters obtained for the α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) are very close to those reported by Muhammad Waseem et al.36 and this further confirms that the WIF is suitable to produce pure α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}). Furthermore, the RBCs have a higher SA and lower PV compare to the α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) with increasing calcination temperature and sulphonation process. This indicates that the RBCs would favor good dispersion of active centers and provide mass-transfer advantages43. Mostafa Feyzi et al.44 reported that the catalytic activity of the solid catalyst is directly dependent on SA, PV and PD. It was reported that the pore structure is a basic requirement for an ideal solid catalyst for biodiesel production. This is because a typical triglyceride molecule has a PD of approximately 5.8 nm. The larger PD (5.740, 5.766, and 5.842 nm) obtained for the RBCs and larger interconnected pores of the triglyceride molecule (5.8 nm) would minimize diffusion limitations of reactant molecules44. However, the PD of the RBCs fall within the range of mesoporous (2–50 nm), an indication of excellent catalytic activity45. Meanwhile, the mesoporous catalyst has been reported for biodiesel production44. The SA of the catalysts is about 4 times higher than the α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) (107.1 m2/g). This result shows the formation of the highly porous structure of the RBCs that can be attributed to the small crystal size as obtained in the XRD analysis37. Hence, the high PV would facilitate the reaction by amplifying the reaction surface44. The crystalline size of the samples as shown in Table 2 further confirms the nanoparticle size of the α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) and RBCs. Therefore, the large surface area, pore-volume, and mesoporous structure of the catalysts would make them excellent in the catalytic property37.

Acidity and basic strength of the α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) and RBCs

In transesterification reaction, the acidity of solid acid catalyst is a crucial factor, as the acidic sites activate the carbonyl groups of triglycerides to initiate the catalytic process31. Also, the alkalinity of the catalyst is another important factor that influences the transesterification activity, as the more the alkalinity of the catalyst, the better the biodiesel yield43,44. As such, absolute values for the surface coverages of the acidic and basic sites of the α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) and RBCs were determined through acid–base titrations and the results are presented in Table 3. From the table, α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) contains 2.21 ± 0.02 mmol g−1 acid value which is very close to 1.89 mmol g−1 reported by Wenlei Xie et al.8. It should be noted that few acid sites were detected on the α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}). The low acidic site of α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) may not be sufficient to catalyze the trans-esterification reaction8. However, the RBC500, RBC700 and RBC900 contain the highly acidic site of 7.84 ± 0.1, 8.92 ± 0.05 and 10.77 ± 0.1 mmol g−1 respectively. These values show that the RBCs possess high acidic site concentrations between 7.8 and 10.7 mmol g−1 and compare well with those of the sulfonated solid superacid catalysts reported in the literature46. But higher than the value of 1.18 mmol g−1 reported by Jabbar Gardy et al.47 and 0.32 mmol g−1 obtained for Fe3+/SO2 catalyst21. The higher acidic values obtained for the RBCs were due to the addition of sulfate groups in the form of SO2 on the catalyst surface19. The acidity of the RBCs confirmed that the sulfonic acid groups covalently attached onto α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) to produce stable solid superacid catalysts. Therefore, the acidic properties of the RBCs can significantly improve the catalytic activity of the solid acid catalysts toward the trans-esterification reaction of WCO to biodiesel8. In addition, the α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}), RBC500, RB700 and RBC900 also possess basic site of 8.14 ± 0.6, 6.36 ± 0.2, 5.89 ± 0.4 and 4.90 ± 0.2 mmol g−1 respectively. All the samples exhibited high basic strength with the α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) having the highest basic sites. The basic strength of the RBCs show a decreasing trend with respect to the addition of ({text{SO}}_{4}^{2 – }) loading. The acidic centres of ({text{SO}}_{4}^{2 – }) submerged in the basic matrix of the α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) resulting in concomitant acidic–basic centers43.

Table 3 Acid–base characterization of the α-({text{Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) and RBCs.

Therefore, the high acid–basic sites obtained for the RBCs reveal the better catalytic activity of the catalysts. As it would be easy for the triglyceride and methanol to diffuse into the interior of the RBCs and contact with more acid–basic active sites44.

Proposed reaction mechanism of the RBCs for biodiesel production

Worthy of note is that the transesterification reaction of triglyceride to produce biodiesel occurs on the surface of the solid catalyst. The RBCs in this study are solid acid catalysts which are composed of Al–O=Fe–O–Fe=O/SO4. Meanwhile, Suyin Gan et al.48 classified ferric sulfate as a solid acid catalyst that is sparingly soluble in methanol and completely soluble in water. It was also assumed that the reaction of ferric sulphate to produce biodiesel is a pseudo-homogeneous route as shown in Scheme 1. The scheme is the reaction of triglyceride with methanol in the presence of solid acid catalyst developed in this study, where all the chemical compounds involved in the reaction are identified as items (a–j).

Scheme 1

Proposed mechanism for the trans-esterification reactions on AlFe2O3/SO4. From Scheme 1, item (a) is the RBCs active chemical compound that was developed from calcination and sulphonation of α-({text{ Fe}}_{2} {text{O}}_{3}) synthesized from WIF. Generally, a reaction catalyzed by mineral acid and metal ions such as Al–O=Fe–O–Fe=O/SO4 generates hydrogen ion (H+) in the initiation step through the protolysis of the ({text{CH}}_{3} {text{OH}}) as shown in item (b). The next stage of the reaction is the protonation of the carbonyl group in the triglyceride by the metal ions in the solid acid catalyst as shown in item (c) to form methyl ester and a diglyceride anion as shown in item (d). This cycle is repeated from item (e) to (f), forming another methyl ester and a monoglyceride anion as shown in item (g). It is repeated the third time as shown in items (h) and (i) to form another methyl ester and glycerol as shown in item (j). From each cycle, Al–O=Fe–O–Fe=O/SO4 component of the RBCs is recovered, which is a good characteristic of solid catalysts.

The functionality of the RBCs

The catalyst types of the RBC500, RBC700 and RBC900 were evaluated for their functionality through simultaneous esterification and transesterification of WCO to produce biodiesel. Optimal process conditions were explored by evaluating the effects of reaction time, MeOH: WCO molar ratio, catalyst loading and reaction temperature on biodiesel yield. Figure 9a shows the effect of reaction time between 30 and 240 min at constant MeOH: WCO molar ratio of 1:6, catalyst loading of 10 wt%, reaction temperature of 70 °C and agitation speed of 800 rpm. The %yield of biodiesel increased linearly to about 70% with the time, 90 min for the RBCs, before reaching a plateau after 180 min, to 87.1, 89.6 and 91.7% for RBC500, RBC700 and RBC900 respectively. At the end of the 240 min reaction time, maximum %yield of biodiesel attained was 87.5, 90.4 and 92.5% for RBC500, RBC700 and RBC900 respectively. The MeOH: WCO molar ratio is an important process condition for the transesterification and this is due to the reversibility nature of the reaction. Therefore the %yield of biodiesel can be increased by using excess methanol to favor the forward reaction8. The effect of MeOH: WCO molar ratio on the catalytic performance of the RBCs were studied at the range of 6:1 and 18:1 mol/mol under process conditions of reaction time = 3 h, catalyst loading = 10 wt%, reaction temperature = 70 °C and agitation speed = 800 rpm. As seen in Fig. 9b, the biodiesel yield increased significantly as the MeOH: WCO molar ratio increases from 6:1 to 12:1 which is because higher methanol concentrations promote oil solubility and hence %yield of biodiesel47. Further increase in the MeOH: WCO molar ratio from 12:1 to 15:1 and 18:1 yielded a marginal increase in the biodiesel yield. Therefore, the appropriate MeOH: WCO molar ratio for the transesterification reaction is considered as 12:1. However, the excess methanol is recyclable through a simple distillation method8. The effect of catalyst loading between the range of 2 and 10 wt% on the yield of biodiesel was subsequently explored keeping other process conditions constant (MeOH: WCO molar ratio = 12:1, reaction time = 3 h, reaction temperature = 70 °C and agitation speed = 800 rpm). The result obtained is as shown in Fig. 9c, when the catalyst loading increased from 2 to 6 wt%, the biodiesel yield increased steadily to 88.6, 91.3 and 92.0% for RBC500, RBC700 and RBC900 respectively. The direct proportionality of the catalyst to biodiesel yield can be associated with the increase in the number of active sites to ensure attainment of equilibrium within a shorter time43. Additional catalyst loadings (8 and 10 wt%) show an insignificant impact on the %yield of biodiesel for all the RBCs. This is an indication that the trans-esterification is reaction-rate limited for catalyst loading of ≤ 6 wt% and that higher catalyst loading is therefore undesirable47. The excess catalyst loading may have enhanced the viscosity of the reaction mixture and hindered the effective mass transfer of the solid catalyst and feedstocks, consequently leading to an insignificant impact to increase the biodiesel yield8. Figure 9d shows the effect of reaction temperature at the range of 50 and 90 °C on the %yield of biodiesel for the RBCs under constant reaction conditions (MeOH: WCO molar ratio = 12:1, reaction time = 3 h, catalyst loading = 6 wt% and agitation speed = 800 rpm). As can be clearly seen, the %yield increased continuously as the temperature increases from 60 to 80 °C. This, however, corroborates the claim that the higher temperature accelerates the trans-esterification reaction rate due to the shift of reaction equilibrium and as such, increase the reactant activation, higher oil miscibility and lower the viscosity of reactants8,47. Further increase in the reaction temperature to 90 °C reveals negligible impact on biodiesel yield which indicates that the reaction had attained equilibrium. Thus, the reaction temperature of 80 °C can be chosen as the suitable temperature for higher biodiesel yield in this study. Generally, prolonged reaction time of 180 min, excess MeOH: WCO molar ratio of 12:1, catalyst loading of 6 wt% and a higher reaction temperature of 80 °C are the process conditions required to achieve a satisfactory biodiesel yield of 87, 90 and 92% for RBC500, RBC700 and RBC900 respectively. This phenomenon shows that RBC900 with higher SA, PV and PD with the smallest average particle size has a better catalytic performance than the other catalysts. Mostafa Feyzi et al.44 observed the same trend in their study.

Figure 9

Effects of (a) reaction time, (b) MeOH: WCO molar ratio, (c) catalyst loading and (d) reaction temperature on the %yield of biodiesel using synthesized RBC500, RBC700 and RBC900.

Therefore, the maximum %yield of biodiesel obtained in this study confirms the functionality of the WIF-based solid acid catalysts which is composed of Al–Fe2O3/SO4. The %yield of biodiesel follows the order of acidity and alkalinity for respective catalyst, therefore the surface acidity was responsible for the high catalytic activity31. Jabbar Gardy et al.47 in their study of SO2/Fe–Al–TiO2 catalyst developed from ammonium hydroxide (28–30%, NH4OH) and ferric chloride hexahydrate (≥ 98%, FeCl3·6H2O) as precursors, attained 95.6% yield of biodiesel. Mostafa Feyzi et al.44 also obtained a 94.8% yield of biodiesel with their developed catalysts of Cs/Al–Fe3O4 from the pure ferric compound as a precursor. Comparatively, the solid acid catalyst developed from WIF achieved a satisfactory yield of biodiesel, just as catalysts derived from a pure ferric compound did.

Reusability test of the RBCs

Figure 10 shows the variation in the %yield of biodiesel with the reuse time for each of the RBCs. As it is observed, no significant loss was noticed in the %yield of biodiesel over the first three consecutive catalytic trans-esterifications, an indication of excellent reusability of the catalysts. However, there was a significant loss in the yield of biodiesel at the fourth cycle to about 72% and the fifth cycle to 65%. The reason for the loss of activity could be associated with the deposition of carbonaceous or organic substrates on the recovered catalyst31. Also, ferric sulphate catalyst though insoluble in oil, it is sparingly soluble in methanol and can dissolve in the water formed during esterification48. This is a usual phenomenon encounter in the use of heterogeneous catalysts particularly in the polar reaction system that leads to a drastic loss of catalytic activity31.

Figure 10

The reusability plot for the RBC500, RBC700 and RBC900.

Characterization of WCO and biodiesel samples produced by the RBCs

Physico-chemical properties

The catalyst type of RBCs was studied for biodiesel production using WCO. The WCO and biodiesel samples obtained from each of the RBCs are shown in Fig. 11. The figure show a color deviation of the biodiesel samples by each of the RBCs from the color of the WCO. The fuel properties obtained by each of the RBCs and the physicochemical properties of the WCO are shown in Table 4 in comparison with the ASTM standards. The values of density obtained are 0.951, 0.868, 0.887 and 0.891 g/cm3 at a temperature of 15 °C for WCO, RBC500, RBC700 and RBC900 respectively. The densities of biodiesel from respective catalysts fall within the standard with a significant deviation from that of the WCO. The results show that the RBCs are suitable to produce appropriate biodiesel for use in compression ignition engines (CIE) since the density is an important parameter that determines the energy content of biodiesel.

Figure 11

(a) WCO, biodiesel produced by (b) RBC500, (c) RBC700, and (d) RBC900 catalysts.

Table 4 Fuel properties of WCO, and biodiesel from WCO by RBC500, RBC700 and RBC900.

Kinematic viscosity (Kv) evaluates the degree of atomization of the biodiesel in the combustion chamber of CIE. The Kv obtained as shown in Table 4 are 25.6, 4.1, 3.3 and 3.9 mm2/s at a temperature of 40 °C for WCO, RBC500, RBC700 and RBC900 respectively. The Kv of the biodiesel samples fall within the range of the standard and this gives an assurance of quality biodiesel that can combust completely in a CIE without leaving residual residues that can cause damage in the engine49. Whereas, Kv of the WCO is about one-sixth far higher than that of the biodiesel samples, an indication of the effect of the trans-esterification process.

Flash point (FP) is an important property that has a direct positive relationship with fluid’s viscosity and it is the tendency to form a flammable mixture in the air50. The FP is the minimum temperature when there is enough concentration of evaporated fuel in the air for the flame to propagate after ignition has been initiated51. As shown in Table 4, the biodiesel samples fall within the standard flash point of ≥ 130 oC. According to Adewale Folayan et al.50, FP determines the transportation and storage requirement of biofuel and should be higher than the standard to ensure safe operation and reduced vaporization within the maximum operating temperature. The findings here show that the biodiesel samples are safe for transportation, storage, and handling in safe operation.

Cloud Point (CP) is the temperature at which the cloud of wax crystals become visible in liquid fuel. This is observed when the fuel is cooled under a controlled environment using the ASTM procedure (ASTM D 2500)49. The CP values of the biodiesel samples obtained are shown in Table 4 as + 7, + 5 and + 5 for RBC500, RBC700 and RBC900 respectively. These values are relatively low compared to the WCO with the CP of + 23 (Table 4). The CP values of biodiesel are of quality, indicative of great performance and good characteristics of fuel in low-temperature climate conditions. This shows that the biodiesel would have a good fuel flow with great fuel pump, filter and injector performances50. On the other hand, pour point (PP) is the lowest temperature when the liquid fuel ceases to flow or be pumped having solidified to resist flow. It is also the dynamic behavior of fuel under varying temperature conditions51. For this work, the PP values of biodiesel obtained are shown in Table 4 as + 3, − 1 and − 1 for RBC500, RBC700 and RBC900 respectively. The values are very low compared to the PP of WCO that is + 15, which is an indication of improved quality due to the catalytic reaction of WCO to biodiesel. The values of PP for the different biodiesel suggest that the fuel types do not have inferior cold flow property as the high value of PP can cause gum formation, crystallization of fuel particles and negatively affect fuel flow and ultimately destroy pump and injector50.

Cetane number (CN) is the characteristics that reveal the ignition quality of a diesel engine fuel as the higher the cetane number, the shorter the delay time (ID), and the better the ignition quality51. Meanwhile, the minimum value of CN recommended by the ASTM standard is 47 (Table 4). The values of the CN obtained for the biodiesel types are 56.49, 58.74, and 64.34 as shown in Table 4, for the RBC500, RBC700 and RBC900, respectively. These values are greater than the minimum standard as well as the CN of WCO (30.51). The high CN in this study may be due to an increasing chain length, increasing branching, and increasing saturation in the fatty acid chain of the biodiesel samples as a result of the trans-esterification by the RBCs52. Based on the standard, the biodiesel samples in this work have good ignition quality53.

FAME analysis

The FAME profile and percentage composition obtained from the GC–MS for WCO and biodiesel samples synthesized by the RBCs are shown in Table 5. The spectra for each of the samples were identified with the NIST MS database as shown in Fig. 12a–d for the WCO and biodiesel samples by the RBC500, RBC700 and RBC900 respectively. From the results obtained, the WCO consists of two FAMEs with their respective percentage composition which includes ({text{C}}_{17} {text{H}}_{34} {text{O}}_{2}) (16.70%) and ({text{C}}_{19} {text{H}}_{36} {text{O}}_{2}) (20.78%) as shown in the table. However, after trans-esterification of WCO with the RBCs, 4 components were identified with their respective percentage compositions, which include ({text{C}}_{7} {text{H}}_{12} {text{O}}_{4}), ({text{C}}_{17} {text{H}}_{34} {text{O}}_{2}), ({text{C}}_{19} {text{H}}_{34} {text{O}}_{2}) and ({text{C}}_{19} {text{H}}_{36} {text{O}}_{2}) as shown in the table. The biodiesel sample produced by the RBC500 possesses higher concentrations of ({text{C}}_{17} {text{H}}_{34} {text{O}}_{2}) (43.20%) and ({text{C}}_{19} {text{H}}_{36} {text{O}}_{2}) (38.19%), and lower concentrations of ({text{C}}_{7} {text{H}}_{12} {text{O}}_{4}) (11.38%) and ({text{C}}_{19} {text{H}}_{34} {text{O}}_{2}) (5.81%)(.) While the RBC700 and RBC900 biodiesel samples present a similar pattern of percentage compositions of the FAME. Based on the FAME analysis, saturated and unsaturated chains present in the biodiesel samples are 43.20 and 55.38% (RBC500), 43.97 and 54.65% (RBC700) as well as 43.51 and 56.48% (RBC900) respectively. This revealed that the biodiesel samples consist of a higher percentage of unsaturated than saturated fatty acids. The major source of saturated FAME in the samples is methyl palmitate while that of the unsaturated FAME is methyl octadecenoate. The high concentration of unsaturated methyl esters (> 54%) in all the biodiesel samples could be responsible for low values of flash point and cloud point obtained in this work49. Furthermore, the high presence of saturated chains (> 43) in the biodiesel samples is responsible for the high cetane number and increased kinematic viscosity recorded in this work54. The presence of > 54% unsaturated methyl esters in all the biodiesel samples produced show a high oxidation and thermal stability since the rate of oxidation is on the high side with the increase in the unsaturated fatty acid chains55. This however, reveals that the biodiesel samples would have a much slower deterioration rate in high-temperature environments and provides long-term storage duration56.

Table 5 FAME profile and biodiesel yield of WCO by RBC500, RBC700, and RBC900.
Figure 12

GC–MS spectra of the (a) WCO, biodiesel samples by (b) RBC500, (c) RBC700 and (d) RBC900.

The density and kinematic viscosity of the biodiesel samples also depends on the higher unsaturated chain. It is worthy to note that the RBC500, RBC700 and RBC900 produced high FAME contents of 98.22, 98.57 and 99.99% respectively from the WCO as shown in Table 5. The biodiesel yields meet the standard quality of biodiesel as expressed by the ASTM D6751 ( > 96.5%)32. Therefore, the biodiesel samples produced by the RBC500, RBC700 and RBC900 are of high quality as they satisfy the ASTM standard.

Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *