# Phonon-exciton Interactions in WSe2 under a quantizing magnetic field

Jun 19, 2020

### Phonon replicas of excitonic particles in monolayer WSe2

The BN encapsulated monolayer WSe2 device was fabricated through a pickup method similar to previous reports5,13,26. The device structure is schematically shown in Fig. 1a, and a typical optical microscope image of the device is shown in Fig. 1b. We investigate the helicity-resolved PL spectra of the monolayer WSe2 as a function of the gate voltage at 4.2 K. The gate-voltage-dependent PL spectra in σσ (σ excitation and σ detection) and σσ+ (σ excitation and σ+ detection) configurations, shown in Fig. 1c, d, exhibit high spectral quality and a series of well-resolved PL peaks arising from various excitonic complexes. A significant number of the excitonic complexes have been identified previously, including the exciton (X0), intervalley n-trions (({mathrm{X}}_1^ -)), intravalley n-trions (({mathrm{X}}_2^ -)), dark exciton (XD)27,28,29, positive, and negative dark trions (({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{D}}^ +) and ({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{D}}^ -))26,30,31. Phonon replicas of the spin-forbidden dark exciton (({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{D}}^{mathrm{R}})) and the momentum-dark intervalley exciton (({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{i}}^{mathrm{R}})) have also been observed previously1,5, due to the long lifetime of the dark excitonic complexes. Because of the valley degree of freedom, angular momentum conservation has to be considered in the phonon–exciton interaction in TMDCs, and the chiral phonon mode is involved in ({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{D}}^{mathrm{R}}) (linear combination of two doubly degenerate E″(Г) or ({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{i}}^{mathrm{R}}) (LO(E′)(K))1,5. In the charge-neutral region (gate voltage from −0.10 to 0.21 V in Fig. 1c, d), one additional PL peak ({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{i}}^{{mathrm{R}}_2}) (1.6788 eV in Fig. 1d) emerges in the σσ+ configuration due to its negative valley polarization. The ({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{i}}^{{mathrm{R}}_2}) is another phonon replica of the intervalley exciton with the LA(K) phonon involved (see Supplementary Note 2 for details), consistent with a very recent report32.

Interestingly, in the highly p-doped region, the PL of the bright trion peak (X+) exhibits a significant redshift after the gate voltage of approximately −2.5 V (Fig. 1a, b), and this gate dependence is closely followed by the dark trion (({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{D}}^ +)), along with five PL peaks labeled as ({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{D}}^{ + ({mathrm{R}}_1)}), ({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{D}}^{ + ({mathrm{R}}_2)}), ({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{D}}^{ + ({mathrm{R}}_3)}), ({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{D}}^{ + ({mathrm{R}}_4)}), and ({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{D}}^{ + ({mathrm{R}}_5)}) (Fig. 2a, b). This constant energy differences between each of the five emerging peaks and the dark trion for different gate voltages suggest that these five peaks are all phonon replicas (associated with different phonon modes) of the long-lived positive dark trion (or dark p-trion). Due to the three-particle nature of the positive dark trion, the electron–hole recombination can occur either in the same valley or across the opposite valley, assisted by Γ (Fig. 2d) or K phonons (Fig. 2c). The ({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{D}}^{ + ({mathrm{R}}_1)}) and ({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{D}}^{ + ({mathrm{R}}_4)}) peaks are lower than the dark trion peak by 13.1 and 26.4 meV, respectively, in good agreement with the theoretically calculated energy of the TA(K) phonon (11.6 to 11.7 meV)1,2,32 and LO(E′)(K) phonon (24.6 or 26.0 meV)1,32, respectively, (see Supplementary Table 1 for details). The phonon replica nature of the ({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{D}}^{ + ({mathrm{R}}_1)}) and ({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{D}}^{ + ({mathrm{R}}_4)}) peaks are also confirmed later by the measured Landé g-factor, which is the same as the positive dark trion within the experimental uncertainty. The ({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{D}}^{ + ({mathrm{R}}_2)}) and ({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{D}}^{ + ({mathrm{R}}_3)}) peaks are ~17.3 and ~21.6 meV below the positive dark trion ({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{D}}^ +), suggesting that they are the phonon replicas involving the LA(K) phonon (calculated energy of 16.8 to 17.0 meV)1,2,32 and E″(Г) (calculated energy of 21.8 meV)5, respectively, also consistent with a very recent report32. It is worth noting that the phonon energy can be experimentally extracted from the phonon replicas of the positive dark trion without worrying about the exchange interaction (see Supplementary Note 3 for details). As the phonon replicas associated with E″(Г), LO(E′)(K), and LA(K) modes are also found in the charge-neutral region, the corresponding peak of ({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{D}}^{mathrm{R}}), ({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{i}}^{mathrm{R}}), and ({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{i}}^{{mathrm{R}}_2}) can then be used to determine the exchange interaction, which is extracted to be 9.3–10.1 meV (see Supplementary Note 3 for details). The phonon modes associated with ({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{D}}^{ + ({mathrm{R}}_1)}), ({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{D}}^{ + ({mathrm{R}}_2)}), ({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{D}}^{ + ({mathrm{R}}_3)}), and ({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{D}}^{ + ({mathrm{R}}_4)}) are schematically shown in Fig. 2e. The corresponding phonon mode replicas can also be found for the negative dark trion (or dark n-trion) except for ({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{D}}^{ – ({mathrm{R}}_2)}), labeled as ({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{D}}^{ – ({mathrm{R}}_1)}), ({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{D}}^{ – ({mathrm{R}}_3)}), and ({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{D}}^{ – ({mathrm{R}}_4)}) (Fig. 2a, b). ({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{D}}^{ – ({mathrm{R}}_2)}) was not observed, possibly due to the strong PL at its neighborhood from the mysterious PL peak M. The PL peaks of M, ({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{D}}^{ + ({mathrm{R}}_5)}), ({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{D}}^{ – ({mathrm{R}}_5)}), and ({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{D}}^{({mathrm{R}}_5)}) remain unidentified (see Supplementary Notes 5 and 7).

### Landau quantization in the PL spectra

A large out-of-plane magnetic field not only lifts the valley degeneracy by lowering the valence band maximum of the K′ valley compared with that of the K valley (Fig. 3e, f); it also induces the valley-polarized LLs. We optically pump the WSe2 in the K′ valley and detect PL from the K′ valley (σσ configuration). In the highly p-doped WSe2 (boxed region in Fig. 3a, b), with an out-of-plane magnetic field of 17 T, we found Landau fan like oscillations emerging in the helicity-resolved PL spectra. These oscillations can be categorized into three sets: one set of parallel strips accompanying the positive bright trion (X+) and the other two sets accompanying the phonon replicas of the dark trion (({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{D}}^{ + ({mathrm{R}}_1)}) and ({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{D}}^{ + ({mathrm{R}}_4)})) (Fig. 3b). We attribute these oscillation features to the LL formation. The energy spacing between the oscillations increases linearly as a function of the magnetic field strength (see Supplementary Note 5), consistent with our interpretation.

The Landau fan patterns can be seen more clearly from PL spectra at the representative gate voltage of −3 V and B field of 17 T, shown in Fig. 3c (corresponding to the horizontal dashed line in Fig. 3b). The PL from the bright trion (X+) shows multiple peaks with even energy spacing of ~7.0 meV (red curve in Fig. 3c). The electron–hole recombination in the K′ valley is constrained by the valley-polarized selection rules in the K′ valley and only the n → −(n−1) transition is allowed20,22. At a given gate voltage, this gives rise to evenly space Landau fans with separation, which can be expressed phonematically as (frac{{ehbar B}}{{mu ^ ast }}), where μ* is the effective reduced mass of exciton. In addition, in the highly p-doped regime, the optically excited electron is mostly at the bottom of the conduction band. Therefore, PL intensity is strongest at the lowest energy peak (associated with the 0 → −1 inter-LL transition) and decreases quickly for higher-energy transition. These behaviors match well with our experimental observation in Fig. 3c. And we show the extracted value of μ* as a function of the gate voltage in Fig. 3d.

Surprisingly, the Landau fan pattern from dark trion phonon replica ({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{D}}^{ + ({mathrm{R}}_1)}) and ({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{D}}^{ + ({mathrm{R}}_4)}) shows remarkably different behaviors: First, the energy spacing of the oscillations is ~3.9 ± 0.2 meV, about half of the value for the bright trion (~7.0 ± 0.2 meV). In addition, the intensity of the oscillations remains largely constant with energy for dark trion phonon replicas. These two distinctive differences suggest that the recombination processes underlying dark trion phonon replicas have very different inter-LL transition selection rules.

In a dark trion phonon replica, the recombination of the electron and hole can either occur in the same valley (K valley here) through emitting a Γ phonon or across the valley through emitting a K phonon (Fig. 2c). We do not observe the LL quantization associated with the Γ phonon replica of the positive dark trion, likely due to the weakened coupling with the Γ phonon in the presence of the large out-of-plane field (see Supplementary Note 4). For the K phonon replica, the electron can recombine with the hole in the other valley by emitting a K phonon. From the Fermi’s golden rule, the inter-LL transition rate from n in K valley to −n′ in K′ valley (minus sign means valence band) is given by33

$${mathrm{P}}_{{mathrm{n}} to – {mathrm{n}}^{prime }} = frac{{2pi }}{hbar }mathop {sum }limits_nu left| {mathop {sum }limits_m frac{{leftlangle { – n^{prime} , – } right|H_{el}left| {m, – } rightrangle leftlangle {m, – } right|H_{ep}left| {n, + } rightrangle }}{{E_{m, – } – E_{n, + } + hbar {upomega}_{{mathbf{K}}{upnu}}}}} right|^2{updelta}left( {E_{n, + } – E_{ – n^{prime} , – } – hbar omega – hbar {upomega}_{{mathbf{K}}{upnu}}} right).$$

(1)

where Hep is the electron−phonon interaction Hamiltonian and Hel is the electron-light coupling Hamiltonian (see Supplementary Note 10 for details). (hbar {upomega}_{{mathbf{K}}{upnu}}) is the K phonon energy with mode ν. |n,+〉 (|n,−〉) represents the LL state in K (K′) valley. The selection rule for optical intra-LL transition is n′ = m + 1. Different from the optical process, the phonon scattering process (langle m, – {mathrm{|}}H_{ep}{mathrm{|}}n, + rangle) is not limited by the selection rules (see Supplementary Note 10 for details). Thus, the phonon–exciton interaction involved here lifts the constraint of inter-LL transition selection rules (see Supplementary Note 10). As a result, electrons in the K valley can recombine with holes in any LLs in the K′ valley, as shown in Fig. 3d. The oscillation spacing will be determined solely by the (Delta _{LL}^V). In addition, the recombination probability will be similar for holes at different LLs in the valence band, as the occupation probability for holes in the first few LLs are all close to unity in the highly p-doped WSe2. This interpretation is consistent with the aforementioned experimental observations.

### Effective mass asymmetry between the electron and hole

Through the oscillation period of phonon replica of the positive dark trion, we can experimentally determine the LL spacing of the valence band (Delta _{LL}^V = frac{{ehbar B}}{{m_h^ ast }}), where (m_h^ ast) is the effective hole mass and B is the magnetic field strength. For the gate voltage of −3 V, the extracted valence band LL spacing is ~3.9 ± 0.2 meV (Fig. 3c), corresponding to (m_h^ ast) ~ 0.50m0, with m0 being the free electron mass in the vacuum. Using the experimentally extracted oscillation spacing as a function of the gate voltage (see Supplementary Note 5), we can extract the gate-voltage-dependent effective hole mass as shown in Fig. 3d. The effective mass of the hole decreases from 0.61m0 to 0.45m0 as the voltage decreases from −2.6 to −4.0 V. The value of ~0.45m0 at the highest p-doping studied in this work (gate voltage of −4.0 V) is close to the theoretically predicted value of 0.4m0, while the much-enhanced value of 0.61m0 indicates strong interactions at the gate voltage of −2.6 V.

At the same time, we also observe the LL quantization of the bright trion, which probes the combined Landau quantization of the exciton. Our top BN flake is ~9 nm thick, which corresponding to a gating efficiency of (2.15 times 10^{12},{rm{cm}}^{ – 2},{rm{V}}^{ – 1}) based on a geometry capacitance model (see Supplementary Note 9 for details). As a result, at the onset of the Landau fan of the bright trion at approximately −2.6 V, the density of hole is estimated to be (5.4 times 10^{12},{rm{cm}}^{ – 2}) (onset of the p-doping at −0.1 V, Fig. 1). In this strongly p-doped regime, we expect a much reduced Coulomb interaction and assume a small exciton binding energy to help extract the effective electron mass20. For the loosely bound electron–hole pair20, the LL of the exciton (frac{{ehbar B}}{{mu ^ ast }}) can be expressed as the summation of the LL spacing of the conduction band ((Delta _{LL}^C)) and valence band (Delta _{LL}^V), i.e., (Delta _{LL}^C + Delta _{LL}^V = frac{{ehbar B}}{{mu ^ ast }}). Therefore, we would have the expression (frac{1}{{mu ^ ast }} = frac{1}{{m_h^ ast }} + frac{1}{{m_e^ ast }}), which we can use to extract the effective electron mass of the electron, (m_e^ ast)19. This picture is confirmed by the observation that the LL spacing from the exciton–phonon complex is always about half of the value for the bright trion for the gate voltage range we studied (Supplementary Fig. 11). Between the gate voltage −3.5 to −2.6 V, the extracted effective mass of the exciton varies from 0.25m0 to 0.38m0 (Fig. 3d), similar to what has been extracted from the absorption spectra of n-doped WSe220. However, the associated effective electron mass is much larger than that of hole, 0.58m0 to 1.01m0 between the gate voltage −3.5 to −2.6 V. At the same experimental condition, this larger effective mass of electron than hole by as large as >50% (Fig. 3d), is in stark contrast to the typical assumption of electron–hole symmetry20,23,24,25.

The electron mass can also be directly extracted for n-doped WSe2, from the Landau quantization of the PL from the phonon replica of the negative dark trion (({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{D}}^{ – ({mathrm{R}}_1)}), see Fig. 3a and Supplementary Note 5). The effective electron mass is extracted to be ~0.8m0 between the gate voltage of 2.25–2.85 V. This value falls in the range of the effective electron mass extracted from the p-doped WSe2 and is also significantly larger than the effective mass of hole.

### Gate-dependent valley-Zeeman shift

Under the out-of-plane magnetic field, the PL peak of excitonic complexes from one particular valley will exhibit a linear shift due to the valley-Zeeman effect (Fig. 4a for K′ valley), which can be used to determine the g-factor and thus the nature of the excitonic complexes1,5,13,26. As shown in Fig. 4b, at the gate voltage of −1 V, the g-factor for the bright trion and dark positive trion is −5.2 and −9.8, respectively, consistent with the previous report11,26,29,34. For the dark trion phonon replica involving K phonons, the g-factor should be determined by the recombination of electron–hole pair from the opposite valleys, which is theoretically expected to be −12 (see Supplementary Note 6). This value agrees well with that of the dark trion replica, −11.6 for ({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{D}}^{ + ({mathrm{R}}_1)}) and −13.1 for ({mathrm{X}}_{mathrm{D}}^{ + ({mathrm{R}}_4)}), confirming that these two PL peaks are the phonon replicas of the positive dark trion.

Interestingly, the magnitude of the g-factor of the bright trion increases significantly when the p-doping increases, with an abrupt change at the gate voltage of −2.6 V (Fig. 4c). This similar enhancement of the g-factor has been observed in the strongly n-doped WSe2 for the plasma mode20,35. This peculiarly abrupt enhancement of g-factor magnitude at the gate voltage of −2.6 V also closely correlates with the significant increase of the effective mass of electron and hole, suggesting the effects of many-body interactions. In fact, it has been shown that, in the highly p-doped regime, the simple trion picture should be better described with the picture of exciton–polaron36, in which the exciton interacts with all the holes in the opposite valley. Future exploration of the phonon–exciton interactions in the presence of valley-polarized LLs will strengthen our understanding of the exciting quantum many-body effects in the monolayer WSe2 platform.